
CORAL's Hawaii Field Manager Liz Foote sent me some disturbing images she captured during a recent snorkel trip to
Molokini Shoal Marine Life Conservation District and other snorkel destinations off Maui earlier this week. She was in the water with a few different so-called "Eco Tour" operators. One company even sells it's tours by inviting guests to join "friendly experts on our unique Eco-Adventure cruises," and that they work "to protect whales, dolphins, all other marine life and their home – the oceans of the world."
Having looked-over all Liz' photos, my question is precisely which part of these Eco Tours is actually "eco," and demonstrating "protection of marine life and their home?"
Is it the floatation marker lines which companies use to create snorkel zones that also happen to abrade coral colonies?


Perhaps it's the float-line spools wedged between living coral colonies?

Or is it the show and tell with marine life out of the water while posing for the tour company videographer?


Is it the marine life carelessly "dropped" back onto the reef?

Is it the crowding and surrounding of an endangered species depriving it of an escape route?

Maybe it's the egregious examples of lack of supervision while guests kick, climb on, and scrape coral colonies with their fins?



Needless to say, when labels like "eco" are used for situations like this, it calls into question any serious commitment to environmental sustainability and suggests green washing. Which is why
CORAL is facilitating a process on Maui and the Big Island to create a set of voluntary marine recreation standards (
just like we created for the Mesoamerican Barrier Reef) for reef-safe diving, snorkeling, boat operation and other aquatic activities. The goal? Help the marine tourism industry formulate a set of best environmental practices and code of conduct that ensures their ecological footprint on their reef is minimal and Hawaii marine protected areas can better meet the States management objectives.
After all, a healthy reef means a healthy business.